Congratulations! You’ve decided to pop the question. But now you’re staring down the sparkling rabbit hole that is picking the perfect engagement ring, and you have no idea where to start. I’ve got your back! Let’s demystify the process and uncover all the essentials for the securing perfect ring, along with a few sneaky shopping strategies to keep this romantic surprise right under your fiancée’s radar.
This article is sponsored by Colonial Jewelers
You Might Also Be Interested In
- Advice From Your Wedding Vendor
- Retro Wedding Inspiration
- How to Make Your Jewelry Sparkle and Shine
- Tips for Finding the Right Gemstone
Sizing: Getting It Right
Nothing is more awkward than a picking the perfect engagement ring for your proposal then attempt to jam the ring on her finger with no luck. If you don’t already know her ring size (it’s okay, most of us don’t), it’s time to get creative.
Borrow a ring: Take one she wears on her left-hand ring finger and take it to a jeweler for sizing.
Create a mold: Press one of her rings into a bar of soap to create a stealthy impression; then go to a jeweler for sizing.
Trace it: Use a piece of paper and pen to outline the inner circle of the ring.
Recon Mission: Enlist a trusted friend or family member to subtly find out her size—preferably someone who can handle top secret missions without spilling the beans.
When in doubt, size up slightly. A ring that is too big can be easily resized smaller.
Band Metals: Making It Last
The band is like the unsung hero of the engagement ring. It holds everything together and sets the tone for the overall look. Here’s a cheat sheet to some popular options!
Gold:
Comes in yellow, white, and rose tones. Measured in karats. 24k is pure gold, but too soft for daily wear. Stick to 14k to 18k for durability.
Rose gold is a romantic, trendy choice, where yellow gold gives a classic vibe.
Platinum:
The heavy hitter of metals—it’s hypoallergenic, durable, and naturally shiny. Platinum rings are usually 90-95% pure platinum, making them stronger and more resistant to wear than gold.
It’s pricier than gold, but if you want something that lasts forever (like your love, aww), it’s worth the investment.
Silver:
Affordable and stylish, but it’s softer and more prone to tarnishing. Not the best for a ring that gets daily wear.
Over time, silver can develop a patina, which is a darker, antique look. Some love the vintage aesthetic, while others might want to polish it back to its original shine.
Plated Metals:
A budget-friendly option, like gold-plated or rhodium-plated bands. They look stunning, but the plating may wear off over time and need replacing. Think of it as giving your ring a spa day every few years.
Opt in for thicker plating (measured in microns) if you want the finish to last longer, especially for rings that will see a lot of wear and tear.
Sneaky Pro-tip: Take a peek at her jewelry collection to see what she already loves. Matching her current style is a foolproof way to pick a winner.
Gemstones: Choosing The Right One
The gemstone is the star of the show, so you’ll want to choose wisely. While diamonds are the classic choice, modern couples are exploring alternatives like colorful gemstones or lab-created diamonds.
Diamonds 101:
Undeniably dazzling! When shopping for these, refer to the 4 C’s:
Cut: Affects how much the diamond sparkles. Round is the most brilliant, while princess, cushion, and oval cuts offer unique vibes.
Color: Graded from D (colorless) to Z (light yellow). Most people can’t tell the difference between a D and an H, so aim for near-colorless unless you’re set on perfection.
Clarity: Measures internal imperfections, or inclusions. Slight inclusions (VS1 or VS2 grades) are invisible to the naked eye and cost less than flawless diamonds.
Carat: Refers to weight, not size. A well-cut smaller diamond can look bigger than a poorly cut larger one.
Moissanite:
A lab-created gemstone that rivals diamonds in brilliance and durability. More affordable and eco-friendly than diamonds, with sparkle that can even outshine its pricier counterpart.
Morganite:
Known for its soft, peachy-pink hue, morganite is a romantic and feminine choice. It’s durable enough for daily wear (ranking 7.5-8 on the Mohs scale) and is typically paired with rose gold to enhance its warm tones.
Sapphires, Emeralds, and Rubies:
Perfect for the nontraditional bride who wants a splash of color. These stones are durable (sapphires and rubies rank 9 on the Mohs scale, emeralds are softer at 7.5-8) and come in a variety of hues to match your partner’s style.
Other Alternative Stones:
Opals, aquamarine, and pearls are stunning choices, but they’re softer and may need extra care to prevent chipping or scratching.
Pro tip: If you’re considering nontraditional gemstones, take note of their hardness and care requirements. A ring worn every day needs to be strong, so if your heart’s set on a softer stone like opal, consider a protective setting like a bezel.
Whether you go classic with a diamond, eco-conscious with moissanite, or bold with a sapphire, the best gemstone for picking the perfect engagement ring is the one that reflects your partner’s unique style and personality.
The cut of a gemstone influences its sparkle, style, and overall vibe. Here are the most popular options:
Round: Classic, brilliant, and the most sparkly. Perfect for traditional styles.
Princess: Square with sharp edges, modern and elegant.
Cushion: A square shape with rounded corners, offering a soft, romantic look.
Oval: Elongated for maximum brilliance and a flattering, slenderizing effect on the finger.
Emerald: Rectangular with step-like facets, sophisticated and vintage-inspired.
Pear: A teardrop shape, ideal for a unique, feminine design.
Marquise: Football-shaped with pointed ends, maximizing carat size for bold flair.
Settings: Framing the Gemstone
Now it’s time to set the stage for the gemstone! The setting showcases the gem’s beauty while keeping it secure. Here’s the most popular settings:
Prong: Classic and minimal, with small metal claws that hold the stone. Great for maximizing sparkle, but higher prongs can snag on clothing.
Bezel: A sleek metal rim encircles the gemstone, offering a modern look and extra protection—perfect for active lifestyles.
Halo: A circle of smaller stones surrounds the center gem, making it look larger and extra dazzling.
Pavé: Tiny diamonds encrusted along the band add sparkle without overwhelming the main stone.
Three-Stone: Features two smaller side stones flanking the center gem, symbolizing the past, present, and future.
Pro tip: Choose a setting that matches your partner’s lifestyle. If they’re always on the go or work with their hands, a bezel or low-profile prong setting is more practical than a high-profile design.
Shopping Tips: Keeping It Sneaky and Smart
Pulling off a surprise proposal takes planning and stealth. Here’s how to shop for the perfect ring without blowing your cover:
Go incognito: Turn off shared devices and accounts to avoid targeted ads giving you away.
Call for backup: Recruit their best friend or a trusted family member to gather intel on styles, sizes, and preferences.
Shop during their busy hours: Use their work schedule or hobbies as cover for your shopping trips.
Picking the perfect engagement ring might seem intimidating, but with a little research and creativity, you’ll find the one that matches your love story. Now go forth, future fiancé! Trust yourself, and soon enough, you’ll be hearing the sweetest “yes” of your life!
Subscribe so you don’t miss a post
Sign up with your email address to receive news and updates!